Claudius Apollinaris

7 February · commentary

ON SAINT CLAUDIUS APOLLINARIS, BISHOP OF HIERAPOLIS IN PHRYGIA.

TOWARD THE END OF THE SECOND CENTURY.

HISTORICAL COMMENTARY.

Claudius Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis in Phrygia (Saint)

By I. B.

Section I: The Homeland and Public Veneration of Saint Apollinaris.

[1] The city of the Hierapolitans is placed in Phrygia Major by Ptolemy, Book 5, chapter 2, and it is the chief of those cities bearing the name "Hierapolis" -- so called, as Stephanus attests, "from having many sacred things," Of the city of Hierapolis, among which were perhaps counted the hot springs that abound there in great number. Some writers place it in Asia Minor, others in Phrygia, which is itself in Asia; Stephanus places it between Phrygia and Lydia; Strabo in Book 13, "opposite Laodicea," on the river Maeander.

[2] Saint Philip the Apostle is said to have been the first to illuminate it with the faith of Christ, converted by Saint Philip, whom the Roman Martyrology proclaims on the Kalends of May as having, "after converting almost all of Scythia to the faith of Christ, at Hierapolis, a city of Asia, been affixed to a cross and overwhelmed with stones, and having come to rest in a glorious end." After Saints Papias and Abercius, Distinguished Bishops then governed it: Saint Papias, a hearer of the elder Saint John and a companion of Polycarp, of whom below at the twenty-second of February; and Saint Abercius, who flourished under the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, as the Martyrology records on the twenty-second of October.

[3] After them, Saint Claudius Apollinaris, born in the same city, was elevated to the episcopate, as Photius in chapter 14 of his Library seems to indicate in these words: Apollinaris was Bishop there, born there, "The author is a Hierapolitan, made Bishop of Hierapolis in Asia." That he was called by the praenomen Claudius called Claudius: is clear from a fragment of the writings of Saint Serapion, Bishop of Antioch, in Eusebius, Book 5 of the Ecclesiastical History, chapter 18, where the following is found: "I have also sent you the letters of the most blessed Claudius Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis in Asia."

[4] Baronius first inscribed his name in the Roman Martyrology on the eighth of January in these words: "At Hierapolis in Asia, Saint Apollinaris the Bishop, who flourished in holiness and learning under Marcus Antoninus Verus." [His name is in the Roman Martyrology on January 8; in many manuscripts on February 7.] He is unknown to the Greek Menaea and Menologion. Many manuscript Martyrologies record him on the seventh of February. Thus the ancient manuscript of Centula, bearing the name of Bede: "In Asia Minor, in the city of Hierapolis, Saint Apollinaris the Bishop, a most learned man." The same, in almost the same words, is found in the manuscripts of Saint Lambert at Liege, of the Carmelites at Cologne, of Trier, of Saint Gudula at Brussels, likewise in the Martyrology printed at Cologne in the year 1490 and in the additions of Hermann Greuen to Usuard, published in 1521. But the very ancient manuscript of the Professed House of the Society of Jesus at Antwerp, also titled under the name of Bede: "In the province of Asia, of Saint Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis, a most learned man." The same is found in the ancient manuscript of the monastery of Saint Lawrence at Liege, which is that of Ado, though subsequently interpolated, and in the manuscript Florarium; and both add: "He flourished in the year 170." June 1. The same Florarium at June 1 reads: "At Antioch, the burial of Saint Apollinaris, Confessor and Doctor." Whether it treats of this or another Apollinaris, we do not know, nor of which Antioch. Could it perhaps be that this our Saint Apollinaris died at Antioch, a city of Caria, situated on the river Maeander not far from Hierapolis, which Stephanus writes was also called Pythopolis, built by Antiochus the son of Seleucus along with Laodicea and Nysa, and given those names from Antiochis the mother, Laodice the sister, and Nysa or Nyssa the wife? Finally, Canisius places the feast of Saint Apollinaris on the twenty-third of July, July 23, on which day Saint Apollinaris, Apostle of the Ravennans, is honored: after his eulogy, he adds: "Likewise the commemoration of another Saint Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis, most famous for his holiness and learning, who left many writings on behalf of the Christian religion."

Section II: The Learning and Writings of Saint Apollinaris; His Zeal against the Cataphrygians; Their Heresy.

[5] What is commended in all the Martyrologies already cited, the learning of this most holy Bishop, is likewise praised by Theodoret in book 3, chapter 2 of the Fables of the Heretics, in these words: "Against these (the Montanists) wrote Apolinarius, Bishop of Hierapolis in Phrygia, he was most learned, a man worthy of praise, who joined outside disciplines as well to the knowledge of divine things." Of him also Photius, cited before, says: "A truly excellent man, and one who used a distinguished style." Trithemius, in his book On Ecclesiastical Writers: "Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis in Asia, a learned man and a distinguished defender of the Christian faith, renowned for his talent and eloquent in speech; he wrote short works not to be despised in the reading, in which he shows himself a man not so much learned as zealous." This our Pierre Halloix, in chapter 3 of the Life of Saint Apollinaris, pronounces to have been said gratuitously and rashly by one ignorant of his writings, and falsely besides. A sharp censure. Surely he who testifies that the man was learned, renowned for his talent, eloquent in speech, and wrote short works not to be despised in the reading, does not deny that he showed himself a learned man, even if he affirms that he was more zealous, zealous, and a distinguished defender of the Christian faith; or rather, that in confuting the errors of the Gentiles and the wiles of the heretics he did not so much wish to display his learning as to defend the innocence and truth of the Christian religion. So Baronius, in his Notes to the Martyrology, says that in the fragments of his writings that survive, the candor of his mind shines out above all else, and of outstanding candor; since he professes that he wishes to write or define nothing in sacred matters by his own wit. When a man of the highest judgment writes this, he does not deny that learning shines out in his writings, but says that candor shines out above it, just as Trithemius says zeal does, that is, eagerness for defending the divine honor and the orthodox religion.

[6] Eusebius treats of the writings of Apollinaris in more than one place. For in book 4, chapter 20, he numbers him with Hegesippus, Dionysius of Corinth, Pinytus, Philip, Melito, Musanus, Modestus, and Irenaeus; "whose right judgment of the Apostolic tradition and of the sound faith," he says, numbered among the illustrious writers by Eusebius. "set forth in writing, has come down to us." And in chapter 25 of the same book: "Of those whom we cited above, Melito, Bishop of the Church of Sardis, and Apolinarius, Bishop of that of Hierapolis, flourished with great renown: each of whom separately offered a book in defense of our faith to the Emperor of the Romans whom we mentioned before in his own time," namely to Antoninus Verus, as he indicated in chapter 18, that is, to Marcus Aurelius Antoninus the Philosopher.

[7] The same Eusebius then, in chapter 26 of book 4: "Of the many writings of Apolinarius, which are preserved among many, these have come down to us: a book to the aforesaid Emperor; five books Against the Gentiles; books written by him; two books On Truth; as many Against the Jews; and those which he afterwards composed against the heresy of the Phrygians, which not long afterwards attempted innovations, and was then beginning, as it were, to sprout, when Montanus, together with his false prophetesses, was making the beginnings of the schism." Of the writings against that heresy, below. Concerning the same Saint Apollinaris and his labors, Saint Jerome, in chapter 26 On Ecclesiastical Writers: "Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis in Asia, flourished under the Emperor Marcus Antoninus Verus, to whom he also gave a notable volume on behalf of the faith of the Christians. There are extant also five other books of his against the Gentiles, and two On Truth, and against the Cataphrygians, who had then first arisen, when Montanus was beginning with Priscilla and Maximilla, the mad prophetesses." Photius testifies that he had read three treatises of his, Against the Gentiles, On Piety, and On Truth.

[8] That heresy of the Phrygians, or Cataphrygians, or Cataphrygae, the Cataphrygians attacked, who arose in the year 171 called by Epiphanius φρυγαστῶν, Phrygastae, commonly Κατὰ φρύγας, "according to the Phrygians," began when Severus for the second time and Herennianus were consuls, in the eleventh year of Marcus Aurelius. So Eusebius in his Chronicle: "The false prophecy which is called that of the Cataphrygians took its beginning, its author being Montanus, with Priscilla and Maximilla, the mad prophetesses." That year is the 171st of the common era. Saint Epiphanius writes that it began to emerge about the nineteenth year of Antoninus Pius, which is the 156th of Christ. Yet I cannot understand in him what he writes, that from the prophecy of Maximilla to the time at which he was writing, namely the twelfth year of the Emperors Valentinian, or in 156 according to Saint Epiphanius Valens, and Gratian, about 290 years are counted: for so read the two Greek editions, of Basel and of Paris, the version of Cornarius in three editions, and that of Petau. But if 290 are added to 156 years, the year 446 will result, which Epiphanius did not reach. It seems that in place of διακόσια ἐννενήκοντα we should restore διακόσια ἐννεακαίδεκα, that is, in place of 290, 219; for these, added to 156, will make 375, which number in the common era falls in the twelfth year of Valentinian.

[9] Concerning these same heretics, Saint Augustine writes the following in volume 6, in the book On Heresies addressed to Quodvultdeus the Deacon, chapter 26: "The Cataphrygians are those whose authors were Montanus, as if the Paraclete, and his two prophetesses Prisca and Maximilla. The province of Phrygia gave them their name, because they arose there and lived there and even now have communities in those same regions. They assert that the coming of the Holy Spirit promised by the Lord was fulfilled in them rather than in His Apostles. Their errors; They hold second marriages to be fornication: and therefore they say the Apostle Paul permitted them because he knew in part and prophesied in part; for that which is perfect had not yet come. And they rave that this perfection came in Montanus and in his prophetesses. They are said to have deadly sacraments. And fatal mysteries, For they are reported to make their so-called Eucharist from the blood of a one-year-old infant, which they extract from its whole body by the wounds of tiny prickings, mixing it with flour and making bread from it. If the child dies, he is held among them as a Martyr; but if he lives, as a great priest." And a little later, speaking of the Pepuzians, he says: "They also make from the blood of an infant what we said above the Cataphrygians do: for they are reported to have sprung from them."

[10] Saint Augustine seems to have drawn these latter details from the Catalogue of Heresies of Saint Philastrius, where he writes about the Cataphrygians after other matters thus: "These baptize the dead, celebrate the mysteries publicly, call Pepuza, their village so named in Phrygia, Jerusalem; where Maximilla and Priscilla reported by certain Fathers, and Montanus himself are known to have spent a vain and fruitless lifetime. Where also the mystery of the Cynics and the execrable impiety regarding an infant is celebrated: for they say that they mix infant blood into their sacrifice at Easter," etc. Our Peter Halloix, in the Notes on chapter 2 of the Life of Saint Apollinaris, contends that Saint Augustine did not believe those unspeakable things and therefore did not affirm that they practiced them, but said that they were reported to do so. The Praedestinatus of Sirmond, at heresy 26, not believed by Saint Augustine, after having related most of the foregoing in the very words of Saint Augustine, adds: "Thus far let me speak of the Cataphrygians. The rest that is said, I pass over as uncertain -- that they take from the blood of an infant. And others, This we say lest we seem to be ignorant of everything that is said about them. For those who have written against them have made no mention of this at all." But Saint Epiphanius, who at length refutes the pseudo-prophecy of Maximilla which they held sacrosanct, does not touch upon those matters.

[11] Theodoret, who was nearly a contemporary of the author of the Praedestinatus, writes as follows about their errors in the passage cited above: "The first author of the heresy which is called 'According to the Phrygians' was Montanus, originating from a certain village located there called Ardaban. Driven by the desire to preside, he called himself the Paraclete and created two prophetesses, Priscilla and Maximilla: and he called their writings Prophetic Books; and he called the village of Pepuza 'Jerusalem.' He also decreed that marriages should be dissolved and introduced new fasts contrary to the custom of the Church. However, he did not undermine the doctrine of the divine Trinity, and he taught the same things as we do about the creation of the world. Those who followed his teaching were called Montanists after him; and from the nation, they were called 'According to the Phrygians'; and finally Pepuzians from the village which he called Jerusalem. Moreover, the prophecies of Priscilla and Maximilla are honored among them above the divine Gospel. Concerning their mysteries, some people spread certain allegations: but they themselves do not confess them, and call that accusation a calumny. Nor acknowledged by them. Some of them, moreover, deny the three Persons of the Divinity in conformity with Sabellius, saying that the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit are the same." So much from Theodoret.

Section III: The Writings and Struggle of Saint Apollinaris against the Cataphrygians, from Eusebius.

[12] But it is better to hear Apollinaris himself, declaring the origin and doctrines of that heresy and refuting them, in Eusebius, Book 5 of the Ecclesiastical History, chapter 15. We shall distinguish the words of the holy Doctor from Eusebius's own narration.

EUSEBIUS: Against the heresy called that of the Cataphrygians, divine power and might, the champion of truth, raised up Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis Saint Apollinaris given by God to the Church as a champion against them, (of whom mention was made in our previous account), as a firm and impregnable bulwark, together with many other most eloquent men of his age. From whose books very many testimonies suited to this history of ours have been collected by us. For a certain one of those whom we have just mentioned, in the beginning of the work which he wrote against the Cataphrygians, first shows how he had been engaged against them without writing and had refuted their errors: He confutes them by word of mouth: for he begins his writing in this manner.

[13] APOLLINARIS: "Although for a long and very protracted space of time, most dear Abercius Marcellus, I have been urged by you to write something against the heresy of the Cataphrygians, I have nevertheless until now restrained myself from that undertaking, not so much because I doubted whether I could convict the false inventions of their errors and strengthen the truth with firm testimonies, long asked to do so also in writing, as because I feared and carefully guarded against seeming to some people to add or establish something to the word of the Gospel of the New Testament (to which it is permitted neither to add nor to take away anything, especially for one who has resolved to lead his life according to the Gospel) that is not entirely comprehended in it. But when recently I was at Ancyra, a city of Galatia, and found the Church in Pontus being tossed by the storms of contention stirred up by this new and unusual -- not, as they call it, At Ancyra he refutes them, Prophecy, but rather (as will be demonstrated afterwards) pseudo-prophecy -- I disputed as much as I could, with God's help, about these very errors of theirs, which are now spreading everywhere, and about the things proposed by them, continuously for many days in the church: He strengthens the Catholics, to such a degree that the Church was not only filled with very great joy but was mightily strengthened in the truth: and those who defended the opposing side, refuted by me at that same moment, lost heart, and all the adversaries of the truth were afflicted with the greatest pain. And when the Presbyters who were in that place, in the presence of Zoticus of Otrenum, our fellow Bishop, demanded that we leave some written record of those things which had been disputed in that discourse against the adversaries of the truth, we by no means did this on the spot, but firmly promised them he finally promises to write, that, the Lord granting us His grace, we would commit it to writing in this place and send it to them without delay."

[14] EUSEBIUS: Having prefaced these and other words at the beginning of the book and having progressed a little in his discourse, he commemorates the author of the heresy of which we have spoken in this manner.

APOLLINARIS: "The origin, the rashness, and the new and recent sect of those heretics, which has stirred up so much dissension and contention in the Church, had the following cause. A certain village is said to be in Mysia of Phrygia, The author of the Cataphrygians was Montanus, which is called Ardaban. There they say that a certain man named Montanus, who had recently come to the faith, while Gratus was then Proconsul of Asia, first burning with a certain insatiable desire of soul in striving for primacy, as soon as he had opened a way for the adversary devil to reach him, a neophyte and ambitious man, seized by a demon, began to be seized by some evil spirit, and suddenly, driven by frenzy and madness of mind, to rave, and soon not only to chatter rashly but to pour forth certain strange utterances and to prophesy contrary to what the custom of the Church, he utters foolish prophecies: both in tradition and in succession handed down from ancient times until that day, required. Of those who at that moment in time received those shadowy and adulterated utterances by hearing, some sternly rebuked him as one endowed with an insane spirit, he is reproved by some, agitated by a demon, driven as if by the wind of false error, and finally greatly disturbing the multitude of people, and forbade him to speak, mindful of the Lord's warning and threat about watchfully guarding against the coming of false prophets: but others, utterly forgetful of the Lord's warning, he has followers, as though elated by the Holy Spirit and the gift of prophecy and insolently puffed up, being deceived by him and led into fraud, vehemently urged that insane spirit, falsely flattering and craftily leading the people into error, that it should no longer allow itself to be prevented from speaking.

[15] "The devil therefore, having contrived by a certain art, nay by the tricks of such false and fraudulent cunning, the ruin of the disobedient; and having been treated by them with great honor, contrary to what he had deserved, and two harlots, false prophetesses: roused and strained their mind, which had fallen from the faith that is according to truth and was lulled in the sleep of error; so that he drove two harlots to that same crime and filled them with an adulterous spirit, by which, no otherwise than Montanus himself, they chattered furiously, foolishly, and in a new and strange manner: that crafty spirit sometimes proclaiming blessed those who delighted in it and gloried in it extravagantly, and puffing them up with the greatness of its promises; sometimes dexterously, and with reasons apt for persuasion, openly rebuking their sins to their faces, so that it might be thought to be even a corrector of vices. Only a few of the Phrygians were wrapped in the darkness of that error: yet that obstinate and arrogant spirit taught its followers to curse the Catholic and universal Church which is under heaven, because that same pseudo-prophetic spirit had been able neither to have access to it open to itself, nor to acquire honor in it. he is cast out of the Church with his followers: For when the faithful who dwelt in Asia had often, and in many places of Asia, come together into one, and had examined the aforesaid doctrine, and had shown it to be profane and detestable, and had condemned it as heresy, thus at length these men were both thrust out of the Church and wholly driven from communion."

[16] EUSEBIUS: After that writer has recorded these things in the first book and has refuted their error in the whole work, in the second book he says this concerning the death of those whom we have pursued above:

APOLLINARIS: "Since, then, they have called us slayers of the Prophets because we did not admit their prophets, who are above all chatterers and talkers (for they proclaim that these are the ones whom the Lord promised He would send to the people), let them now answer us before God: Pray, my good men, is there found anyone of those who, trained in the discipline of Montanus and those women, began to chatter, none of them suffered for the faith: who either suffered persecution from the Jews, or was delivered to death by the wicked and criminal Gentiles? Certainly no one. Nor was any one of them ever seized and fastened to a cross for the name of Christ: nor was any of those women ever beaten with scourges in the synagogues of the Jews, or overwhelmed with stones.

[17] And as for Montanus himself and Maximilla, they are said to have perished by a wholly different kind of death. For it is reported that, driven by the impulse of an insane and ruinous spirit, Montanus and Maximilla hang themselves with a noose: they took their own lives by a noose: not at the same time, indeed; yet at the time when each of them perished, there was much talk among the people that they had died, as we said, and had met the same end of life as Judas the traitor. In like manner also concerning the remarkable Theodotus, [Theodotus, a supporter of their cause, is snatched up into the air by a demon and cast down and perishes,] who first undertook what amounted to the management of that counterfeit prophecy, the report was very widespread that, driven out of the power of his mind and having entrusted himself to a deceitful spirit, he was once lifted aloft into the air by it and suddenly hurled headlong down, and perished miserably and utterly. They deny that it happened thus. But since we ourselves did not see it, what can we think we know of these things, O blessed one? For Montanus, Theodotus, and that woman mentioned above perhaps died thus, perhaps otherwise.

[18] Eusebius: Again in the same book he says that the holy and pious Bishops of that time attempted to refute and restrain the spirit of Maximilla: but were prevented by others, namely those who were eager to defend that spirit. For he writes thus:

Apollinaris: Let the spirit of Maximilla no longer speak, as Asterius Urbanus in his book introduces her speaking: The lying spirit of Maximilla is restrained by the Bishops, "I am pressed by the persecution of all, and I am driven away from the sheep like a wolf. I am not a wolf: I am indeed the word, the spirit, and the power." But let that spirit effectively demonstrate its power, and let it convict and compel to confess through the spirit those who were then present to examine and dispute with that garrulous spirit -- men of repute and Bishops, Zoticus from the village called Comana, and Julian from Apamea: who are hindered by certain persons: whose mouths Themiso and his associates stopped, and would by no means allow that lying and crafty spirit to be refuted and rebuked by them.

[19] Eusebius: In the same book again, with other things interposed, in order to disprove those fabricated prophecies of Maximilla, she predicts wars, he both indicates the time at which he himself wrote, and recalls her predictions by which she prophesied that there would be wars and uprisings, whose fictions he refutes in this manner:

Apollinaris: How can it be that this falsehood of hers is not already sufficiently clearly discerned by all? For from the time when that woman departed this life, which did not follow. it is already the fourteenth year, and we have not yet heard of any war waged separately in any region, or generally throughout the whole world: on the contrary, by the bounty of God's mercy, a stable peace has remained even for the Christians.

Eusebius: So much from the second book. From the third I shall also produce a few words, in which he attacks the rivals of Montanus, who boasted with vain ostentation that they had many Martyrs, in this manner:

[20] Apollinaris: Since all their arguments which we have set forth above have now been completely refuted, and they have nothing more to say, they take refuge in Martyrs, and affirm that they have many Martyrs: the Cataphrygians falsely boast of having Martyrs, and that this is a sure proof of the power and might that is hidden in their prophetic spirit. But this, as it seems, is utterly alien from the truth. For not a few champions of other heresies also claim to have very many Martyrs: yet we shall not on that account agree with them, nor confess that they possess the truth. Those who were first called Marcionists from the heresy of Marcion like the Marcionists; proclaim that they abound in very many Martyrs of Christ: but yet they by no means confess Christ Himself as the truth requires.

Eusebius: Not long after he adds the following.

Apollinaris: As soon as men who were truly Churchmen and Catholics, during times of persecution, together with some who were blinded by the heresy of the Cataphrygians (whom those heretics regarded as Martyrs), were by chance called to the testimony of the faith which is from the truth, Catholic Martyrs shun the company of both groups, they disagreed with them very greatly: and lest they should seem in any way to consent to the spirit of Montanus and those women, they absolutely refused to communicate with them to their very last breath. And that this is true, and was done in our times at Apamea, which is situated near the Maeander, Gaius and Alexander, born at Eumenia, who were then undergoing martyrdom, declared with sufficient clarity.

[21] Eusebius, chapter 16: In the same volume the same author mentions the writer Miltiades, Saint Apollinaris cites the writings of Miltiades: as one who himself also wrote a book against the aforesaid heresy. For having produced certain of his words, he adds thus:

Apollinaris: Having found these things in a certain treatise of the brother Miltiades, where he demonstrates that a Prophet ought not to speak in ecstasy, I reduced them to a compendium.

[22] Eusebius: Then, having proceeded somewhat further, he enumerates those who prophesied in the New Testament, among whom he numbers a certain Ammia and Quadratus, speaking thus:

Apollinaris: But this false prophet, whose prophesying in ecstasy is accompanied by shamelessness and audacity, having begun with willful ignorance, would lapse into an involuntary insanity of soul, as was said before. He says Montanus prophesied in a frenzy, which is not customary for a Prophet; But they will be unable to show that a Prophet was agitated by the spirit in that manner either in the Old or the New Testament; they will not boast that Agabus, or Judas, or Silas, or the daughters of Philip, or the aforesaid Ammia of Philadelphia, or Quadratus, or finally any others except those of their own number, prophesied in this way.

Eusebius: Again, after a few words, he writes thus:

Apollinaris: For if after Quadratus and Ammia of Philadelphia those women of Montanus received the grace of prophecy, as they say, nor did they have successors of their prophecy, let them demonstrate who among them succeeded Montanus and the women. For the Apostle considers that the Spirit of prophecy ought to endure until the last coming of Christ. But not even now, when the fourteenth year is passing since the death of Maximilla, are they able to show this.

[23] So far Eusebius, and in him Apollinaris, as we shall prove in the following section, since our Halloix brought this into dispute. Those who are here named by him, Gaius and Alexander, Saints here named by Apollinaris, crowned with martyrdom at Apamea on the Maeander, not far from Hierapolis, are venerated on March 10; Saint Julian, Bishop of Apamea (whether of this one, or of the one in Syria, we shall then inquire) on December 9; Saint Zoticus, Bishop of Comana in Pontus, on July 21; whether the latter is the same as Zoticus of Otrus, whom Apollinaris above at number 13 calls his fellow-priest or co-Bishop, I shall not easily determine: for if they are the same, why is he now called of Otrus, now from the village of Comana? Could it perhaps be that, born at Otrus, a city of Phrygia, he was Bishop of Comana? But he who is called "Otrenus" by Eusebius is called "Ostrenus" by Nicephorus, book 4, chapter 43; making mention, he says, of a certain Zoticus, Priest of Ostrenus.

Section IV. The Writings Already Cited, Attributed to Saint Apollinaris. The Sanctity of the Cataphrygians Before Their Secession Refuted.

[24] Our Petrus Halloix, in chapter 3 of the Life of Saint Apollinaris and in his Notes, [whether the writings cited are those of Apollinaris, our P. Halloix doubts, bringing five arguments:] calls into question whether what has already been cited from Eusebius was written by Saint Apollinaris; and pronounces that it does not seem that he wrote them. For, he says, Eusebius does not assert this, but only that a certain one of those he had previously named thus begins his work; and never uses here the formula he employs elsewhere, "Thus says Apollinaris"; and consequently did not consider him to have been the author of that work. Second, that Apollinaris, as shown from Eusebius and Saint Jerome in section 2, number 7, wrote against the Cataphrygians when they first arose; but the author cited by Eusebius wrote only in the fourteenth year after the death of Montanus and Maximilla. Third, that it does not seem likely that Apollinaris, a Phrygian by nation and a Bishop in Phrygia, would have spoken so ambiguously and doubtfully about the homeland of Montanus, a village, that is, of the same Phrygia: "There is said to be a certain village in Mysia near Phrygia, named Ardaba. There, they say, a certain man..." etc.; but would have written plainly: "There is a village in Phrygia," etc.; "there a certain Montanus," etc. Fourth, that Eusebius, when reviewing the writings of Apollinaris, was ignorant of the number of books against the Cataphrygians, or at least did not publish it; yet he enumerated three books of that anonymous author. Fifth, and finally, that this author professes to have reduced certain writings of Miltiades against that heresy into a compendium: which is not characteristic of one who was greater than Miltiades in age, dignity, learning, and authority.

[25] Such are the arguments of Halloix: which have very little solidity. For the first and fourth arguments might perhaps seem to establish only this, [the first and fourth are refuted, that Eusebius did not report this; the second, that these were written later:] that to Eusebius the work of Apollinaris against that sect did not seem to bear the author's name prefixed: and therefore he did not know the exact number of books when he was enumerating the writings of Apollinaris; nor the name, when he was excerpting from those same books what we have cited. This was supplied by Rufinus, who could have known it from other sources. For as to the argument that Apollinaris is said to have written against the sect when it first arose, nothing else follows from this than that it was refuted by him not as by Saint Epiphanius and others, two hundred or more years after the unhappy origin of that heresy, but at its very beginnings, whether the author was still alive or had already died. Are not some sects still considered new, even when the founders have died, if they did not have a long enough life to disseminate their poison? Were not certain works published after the death of the authors in our own age, and as it were posthumous? Baronius considers that Maximilla died in the last times of Marcus Aurelius, and that Apollinaris wrote those things in the last years of Commodus. Is it so remarkable that he flourished in reputation for learning, with works already published, in the year of Christ 171, the eleventh of Marcus Aurelius, and then in 190 or 191, the eleventh or twelfth of Commodus, published still other books? Eusebius also, in the passage cited above, having reviewed his other commentaries, adds that after these he wrote against the heresy of the Phrygians; when, that is, for a long time Abercius Marcellus had been urging him to do so, as was said above at number 13.

[26] But from what does it follow that Apollinaris was greater than Miltiades in age and learning? Because the former is said to have flourished under Marcus Aurelius, fifth, that he cites Miltiades, who was younger than Apollinaris: the latter under Commodus? Apollinaris did indeed write under Marcus Aurelius, but he could also have written a few years later under Commodus. Miltiades may have flourished in reputation for learning under Marcus Aurelius and only finally written under his son. Dignity, and the authority that derives from it alone, is no obstacle preventing a Bishop from citing or even reducing to a compendium and inserting in his own commentaries the writings of a private person, even one younger, even one holding a lesser third, that he seems to doubt about the homeland of Montanus, reputation for learning than himself. For as to the fact that he writes, "There is said to be a certain village," etc. -- does Halloix think that any one Bishop in a very extensive region that numbers fifty bishoprics is not permitted even to be ignorant of the smallest village? What if someone here writes, whether a Bishop or some other learned man, "There is said to be a certain village in Frisia named Blessum," will he be considered to have betrayed inexcusable ignorance, even if he has never visited Frisia? But how much farther did Mysia, situated near the Hellespont, lie from Hierapolis than the village of Blessum, which Ortelius places near Leeuwarden the metropolis of Frisia, lies from Antwerp? I myself have sometimes inquired of a learned man writing the history of Liege concerning certain villages situated in that diocese and province. But he knew neither where they were nor whether they belonged to the diocese. What fraction of Phrygia would the diocese of Liege be, however extensive? We impose too harsh a law upon writers if we allow them to be ignorant of nothing. But he who speaks thus is not even ignorant, but does not wish to affirm what he says except on the basis of report. How often does Cicero and others use that formula?

[27] But Rufinus, nearest in time to Eusebius, translated him into Latin thus in book 5, chapter 15: But against the heresy of the Cataphrygians, Apollinaris of Hierapolis, Saint Apollinaris is attributed these writings explicitly by Rufinus; whom we mentioned above, brought forth a most powerful shield, and many other most learned men from those same regions fought against them in defense of the truth: who also left us most powerful defenses for the weaving of our history. Meanwhile, as we said, Apollinaris, writing against this heresy and indicating in his preface that traveling through the Churches of Galatia and the neighboring provinces, and seeing very many entangled by them, he had corrected many both in person by disputing with them; yet being asked by the Brethren, he also transmitted these written works to them. This and other things Rufinus says; but what was related at number 18 concerning the Bishops Zoticus and Julian, and which in Greek reads thus: "whose mouths those around Themiso stopped and would not allow the false and people-deceiving spirit to be refuted by them," he himself draws to a different meaning, as if Themiso had been an assistant to Julian and Zoticus, who was a Montanist: Zoticus, he says, from Cumana and Julian from Apamea, having undertaken to restrain the spirit that spoke in Maximilla, ordered Themiso to stop her mouth and exclude the voice of the false and wandering spirit, which was also done.

[28] Nicephorus Callistus, book 4, chapter 23, goes in the same direction as Rufinus: Splendidly indeed, as we previously reported, Nicephorus Callistus, Apollinaris of Hierapolis wrote against this sect, who immediately at the beginning of his work shows that he had also fought against it with arguments and refutations without writing. He wrote that book, moreover, to a certain Abercius, beginning thus: "Dearest Abercius Marcellus," etc. This Abercius seems to have been an honored man, and perhaps a relative of Saint Abercius, who, as we said, was the Bishop of Hierapolis before Saint Apollinaris, and, as Halloix reports in his Life, was born at Hierapolis. Whence a not unfounded conjecture would arise that the writer not named by Eusebius was Apollinaris, even if the testimony of Nicephorus and Rufinus did not sufficiently establish it: Baronius, to which Baronius subscribes under the year 173, number 9, ascribing to Apollinaris everything that we have cited from Eusebius, whom he also cites.

[29] Whether Montanus and his followers initially lived in a holy and chaste manner? Halloix reports something else about the Montanists in the Life of Saint Apollinaris that we can by no means approve. It is credible, he says, that they were in the Catholic Church of a holier and more severe discipline, and likewise of more upright chastity, and richer in the true gifts of prophecy than most others: and that they did not condemn second marriages but discouraged them: and likewise that from a zeal for abstinence, not for glory, they chose three Lenten seasons. All of which things were therefore of a greater and singular perfection, and not at all to be censured ... But indeed when in the course of time, ungrateful for God's gifts and puffed up by the wind of pride and ambition, they declined to worse things, then prophecy began to waver, and they themselves to utter false things in place of true; then to condemn second marriages; then to defend their customs against the judgment of the Church; then finally to fall headlong and be wrapped up in errors, etc.

[30] But Saint Apollinaris himself refutes these things in the words already cited, when he says that Montanus, first, or most recently, namely, soon after his conversion aspiring to primacy, converted to the faith, τῶν νεοπίστων πρώτως; then, soon inflamed with an immoderate desire of primacy, when he had given the demon access to himself, suddenly (as Rufinus explains) being brought into a certain ecstasy of mind, and as if driven by a spirit, began to speak out certain new things, different from those which had been handed down to the Church by the succession of the elders, possessed, uttering them as if under a prophetic appearance. Where are those things which Halloix praises, the gifts of true prophecy, where the holier discipline, and thus prophesying, if, as soon as he gave his name to Christ, he aspired to primacy, and was seized by a demon, and so prophesied in no other way than in that frenzy? Remarkable indeed was the chastity of that sect, whose author was possessed, and whose helpers, taken up by him, and its most celebrated prophetesses, were harlots! and having harlots as his helpers. For the fact that in the beginning they did not dissent from the Church on many heads would not on that account have brought less harm, nay perhaps much more, since what seems small is from time to time neglected. That alone was enough and more than enough to be ruinous, that the answers of a demon were received as the oracles of the Holy Spirit. So that it is not at all surprising that so many most learned men rose up at once with so great an effort to crush that sect, and among them our Saint Apollinaris.

Feedback

Noticed an error, have a suggestion, or want to share a thought? Let me know.