ON THE HOLY MARTYRS PAUL AND PRIMITIVUS, OR PRIMITIVA, IN PORTUS ROMANUS.
CommentaryPaulus, Martyr in Portus Romanus (St.) Primitivus or Primitiva, Martyr in Portus Romanus (St.)
By the author G. H.
[1] Portus Romanus, the second episcopal city adorned with the dignity of a Cardinalate, is distant eighteen miles from the City on the right bank of the Tiber, not far from Ostia, the first episcopal city with the prerogative of the Cardinalate. This Portus is now an ignoble retreat of fishermen's huts, In Portus Romanus once famous for the most noble buildings: and it is variously called, now simply Portus, now with a cognomen added -- Portus Romae, Portus Romanorum, Portus Urbis, Portus urbis Romae, Portus Augusti, etc. -- and frequently in the Roman Martyrology, Portus Romanus: many Martyrs were there, in which very many Saints were crowned with the palm of martyrdom. Among these is preeminent St. Hippolytus, Bishop of that same place, from whom the remaining Bishops of Porto are also called Bishops of St. Hippolytus: him and the other Martyrs who suffered in Portus Romanus the Roman Martyrology celebrates on August 22; on which day also, inscribed in the ancient MS. Roman Martyrology attributed to St. Jerome, on this day Paul and Primitivus are celebrated: they are celebrated in Portus Romae. This same MS. Martyrology opens the day of February 24 thus: On the sixth day before the Kalends of March, at Rome in Portus, the birthday of Paul and Primitivus. The ancient MS. of Reichenau also begins with these Saints, but with Portus omitted: At Rome, of Paul and Primitivus. But the MS. of Aachen assigns the place with some doubt, in these words: At Rome, Absolonas, the Birthday of Primitivus and Paul. But what is that Absolonas? Notker makes it a Saint. Likewise, he says, at Rome, of Absolonis. But the same is read in the MS. of St. Jerome and is joined with the Martyrs who suffered at Caesarea in Cappadocia, so that the name appears to have been wrongly transferred and inserted here. Whence we think the preceding entries in that Martyrology should be arranged thus: At Caesarea in Cappadocia, the Birthday of Sts. Herodius, Lucius, Sergius, and Absolon. At Rome, the Birthday of Primitivus and Paul. The former we have relegated to the Catalogue of those Omitted, at the sixth day before the Nones of March. The latter are also reported by Greven in the Supplement to Usuard printed in the years 1515 and 1521: At Rome, of the holy Martyrs Primitivus and Paul.
[2] With Paul omitted, Primitivus alone is celebrated in the ancient MS. Martyrologies of St. Martin at Tournai and of Liessies in these words: By others Primitivus alone is mentioned, At Rome, the birthday of Primitivus. Against this, produced from five ancient MS. Martyrologies of the best reliability and confirmed by the authority of Greven, formerly twice printed, is objected the MS. Martyrology of St. Cyriacus, in which the following is found: At Rome, the Birthday of St. Primitiva. or Primitiva. Thus in our transcript, Rome is written with a diphthong, and Primitiva without a diphthong, so that an error of copyists could easily have crept in from Primitivi. Hence, however, Baronius inscribed in the present Roman Martyrology: At Rome, of St. Primitiva, Martyr. And he notes that the ancient manuscripts, of which he has made mention above, namely of the monastery of St. Cyriacus, agree concerning her, as he has often noted elsewhere. Ferrarius also in the Catalogue of the Saints of Italy says: Primitiva, a Martyr, is mentioned only in the Roman Martyrology. Whether she was married or a Virgin, and under which Emperor she suffered martyrdom, where her body rests, is entirely unknown. Which has also happened with many others, of whom only the bare memory survives. Add also that a single letter of someone's name can easily be confused, as appears to have happened here.
[3] Another controversy concerning the Martyr Paul is whether he should be transferred from this February 24 to the sixth day before the Nones of March, Whether the same Paul is reported by others on March 2. because on that day the following is read in the Roman Martyrology: In Portus Romanus, of the holy Martyrs Paul, Heraclius, Secundilla, and Januaria. Baronius annotates: Bede treats only of Paul and omits Heraclius, but he is restored from the said ancient manuscripts. The words of Bede are: In Portus Romanus, of Paul, Secundola, and Januaria. Galesinius, citing Bede alone, added Heraclius, who is joined by others to another class of Martyrs. In the MS. Martyrology of St. Cyriacus only the following is found: On the sixth day before the Kalends of March. In Caesarea of Cappadocia, of Luke the Bishop, Primitivus, at Rome of Paul, Januarius. In the MS. of Tournai the following is read: In Caesarea of Cappadocia, the Birthday of Luke the Bishop, Januarius, and Primitivus. On the same day in Portus Romanus, in the cemetery of Paul, the Birthday of Secundola and Januaria, Virgins. In these Martyrologies, Paul was not joined above to Primitivus: but Greven joins them both on February 24, as we said, and on March 2, in the Supplement to Usuard, in these words: At Rome, of Sts. George, Heraclius, Absolonius, Paul, Januarius, Primitivus, Secundola. These are read in the following manner in the MS. of Reichenau: At Rome, of Primitivus, Erolius (read Heraclius), George, Absolon, Secundula, Januarius. In the MS. Martyrology of St. Jerome these are distinguished differently: At Caesarea in Cappadocia, of Lucius the Bishop and Primitivus. At Rome, of Secundula, Januaria. In the MS. of Aachen, finally, the following is reported: The Birthday of St. Lucius the Bishop. On the Appian Way, at St. Sixtus, the Birthday of Sts. George, Heraclius, Absolon, Paul, Januarius. In Caesarea of Cappadocia, of Luke the Bishop, Primitivus. And these are the Martyrologies that mention these Martyrs on both days: if others should find more certain information and suggest it, we shall bring it forward at the second day of March.