Monan

1 March · commentary

CONCERNING ST. MONAN, ARCHDEACON OF ST. ANDREWS IN SCOTLAND.

ABOUT THE YEAR 870.

Preliminary Commentary.

St. Monan, Archdeacon of St. Andrews in Scotland.

[1] There is a province of Scotland called Fife, which received its name from Fifus Duff, a brave man, to whom King Kenneth is said to have given it more than 800 years ago: extending far to the east between the two estuaries of the Forth and the Tay, in which the archiepiscopal city of St. Andrews faces the open ocean. Here, around the very times of Fife and Kenneth, namely in the ninth century of the Christian Era, St. Monan served as Archdeacon, who is commonly called St. Mynnan. St. Monan, Archdeacon in Scotland, He was a companion of St. Adrian, Bishop and Martyr, about whom we shall treat on March 4, a fellow traveler, as is said, and helper in his Apostolic labors, and the chief minister of sacred rites. Both, together with several companions, are narrated to have come by ship from Hungary or Pannonia to the eastern parts of Scotland, which were then occupied by the Picts, out of zeal for the Christian religion, as the Aberdeen Breviary, printed, as we said above, in the year 1509, has it. he was not a Hungarian by nation, Although, as Hector Boece reports, others suppose that they were gathered together as a band from the Scots and the English: which seems to us also much more credible. For at that time the Huns, or Avars, held Hungary, barbarians and capital enemies of the Christian religion, and that already for some centuries; so that these Saints can by no means be thought to have fled from there on account of their ferocity then first raging. Nor, if they had been born in Noricum or in the neighboring territory of the Boii, was there any reason why they should set out in such numbers for such remote lands for the sake of religion, either of defending it, which was flourishing at home, or of spreading it: since close at hand were the Moravians, and the Slavs, the Wends, and the Carantanians, and other peoples, in the greatest need of cultivation, being still either wholly without the divine mysteries or only lightly tinged with them; whereas among the Picts and Scots the knowledge and practice of them flourished after a fashion.

[2] It seems far more probable, then, that Monan and those other Martyrs and Confessors were either Scots, but rather a Scot: whether already dwelling in Britain or new arrivals from Ireland, who wished to imbue with piety and a suitable discipline of morals the Picts, or other peoples brought in from elsewhere by Kenneth, King of the Scots, to cultivate the lands of the Picts, the native inhabitants having been wonderfully diminished; or at least (which, however, I should not easily believe) English, or Gauls or Belgians, nearer indeed, and more abounding at that time in teachers of religion than the Pannonians or Noricans. Yet what Boece writes about the Picts, book 10, page 206, I do not think can be established by the certain testimony of any old author: namely, that the Danes, who under the Generals Hungar and Hubba then harassed Scotland and England, the Danes laying waste Scotland in the 9th century and among other innumerable slaughters killed St. Adrian and his companions on the Isle of May, put forward as the cause of the war against the Scots that the wretched remnants of the Picts had conferred on them every right that they had to the kingdom in Albion (from which, almost the whole nation having been slain, they had been unjustly driven by the arms of the Scots). Certainly another proper cause is brought forward by the old writers which drew these two Generals into England, besides that general one, that the Danes or Normans, already accustomed to piracy before, had begun to harass not only the sea-coasts of Belgium and Gaul, pirates, but also the interior regions; roused chiefly by the occasion of the wars which were being wickedly waged between the kindred Kings of the Franks, the grandsons of Charlemagne, stirred up by evil counselors: roused by the Frankish wars, for the punishment of crimes, perhaps also called in by some of them. But chiefly, for the punishment of the crimes which Christians were committing everywhere, God permitting, those savage nations, coming out of the North, shook the whole of Europe far and wide: coming (as St. Abbo of Fleury, nearest to those times, writes in the Life of St. Edmund, King and Martyr), "coming, I say, hardened by the cold of their malice, from that summit of the earth where he set his seat who through pride desired to be like the Most High." "Which nations," the same writer says a little later, "it is certain are so cruel by natural ferocity as indeed being cruel, that they do not know how to be softened by the sufferings of men, since certain peoples among them feed on human flesh." as are the other Northern nations, And presently he adds that such nations abound in very great numbers below Scythia near the Hyperborean mountains, the first to adhere to Antichrist; "which, as we read, are to follow Antichrist before all nations, so as to feed without any pity on the torments of men who will not carry the mark of the beast on their foreheads."

and that St. Mynnan gave sound and pious counsel, we do not deny, although it is by no means proved by the testimony of the ancients; but we utterly deny that he is different from St. Monan.

[3] But from whatever cause that monstrous tempest then arose from the North, which threw almost all the Western provinces into confusion, there lived at that time in that part of Scotland which, as we have said, lies on this side of the estuary of the Tay, St. Adrian the Bishop crowned with martyrdom St. Adrian the Bishop, and on the Isle of May, with Saints Stolbrand, Glodian and very many others, he endured martyrdom to the end. To these Martyrs St. Monan is added by John Leslie, David Camerarius, and Thomas Dempster. Boece seems to be in doubt, or at least to take him and St. Caius for one and the same, and others with him: thus enumerating the Martyrs: "Adrian, the venerable Prelate, Glodian, Gaius, but not St. Monan: (as others say) Monan, Archdeacon of St. Andrews, Stolbrand the Bishop." From which words either this sense must be drawn, that besides Gaius Monan too, as others say, was among those Martyrs; or that Gaius, as others say, was the same as Monan: or perhaps he had written, "Caius, or Gaius, as others say; Monan," etc. The former sense is more approved by me: George Conn seems to have preferred the second, who, omitting Monan, makes Caius the Archdeacon. In the Breviary cited Monan is Archdeacon, but a Confessor: Caius likewise a Confessor: he, however, is placed with the other Martyrs on the fourth of March.

[4] The Martyrology published at Cologne in the year 1490 mentions St. Monan at the Kalends of March thus: he is inscribed in the Martyrologies on March 1: "On the same day, of St. Monan, Confessor." Hermann Greven, in his addition to Usuard published in the years 1515 and 1521: "In Scotland, of Monan, Levite and Confessor." But the manuscript Florarium makes him a Bishop: "In England," it says, "of Monan, Bishop and Confessor." Adam King in his Calendar: "Mynnan, Archdeacon, Confessor in Scotland under King Constantine": the Second, that is, of that name. Dempster in the Scottish Menology: "In Scotland, of Minnan the Archdeacon." But in the Ecclesiastical History of the Scottish nation, book 12, he makes St. Monan and St. Minnan different, each an Archdeacon, each famous for published books. And he writes that by St. Monan were composed Letters to various persons, book 1; Sacred Poems, book 1; the same as St. Minnan: and that at last he was crowned with martyrdom with St. Adrian. But of the other, citing no author except the Scottish Breviary (which, if it is the Aberdeen one, does not have these things), Dempster reports this: "St. Minnan the Archdeacon flourished with a celebrated name both for piety and for learning, most dear to King Kenneth, with whom he traveled through the whole kingdom: and when he was dead, because he could not bear the abandoned luxury of King Donald V, he withdrew from the court: after the latter's bitter death, he was again held in great esteem with King Constantine II. He wrote On the lawful union of the Pictish kingdom with the Scottish, book 1; Apology for the King, book 1. He lived in the year 878. He is venerated on the 1st day of March. There is a church to him in Galloway, named Kilminnan."

[5] So he, though these things are not indicated by a word by the writers of Scottish history who treat at length of Kenneth, Donald and Constantine: and indeed they are by no means consistent with what these writers narrate. For who would believe that a wise and holy man flourished in such favor with Kenneth as Dempster says, whether an intimate of King Kenneth, and was his perpetual companion in traveling through the kingdom, and did not hinder the monstrous cruelty with which those writers relate that he raged against the Picts, sparing no age or sex, nor even the Priests, until he had destroyed the whole nation by extermination, which Pagans would scarcely do in the midst of barbarism? But Kenneth was not so ferocious (as we think) as those affirm who proclaim his wisdom in making laws, his zeal in cultivating religion, and not only his magnanimity in waging wars. He himself certainly, and his two sons Constantine and Ethus, are named Kings of the Picts in certain old annals in Ussher, On the Origins of the British Churches, chapter 15, page 719, who gathers from this (and rightly, in our judgment too) that the Picts, who through his grandmother was heir to the Pictish kingdom, although already subject to the rule of the Scots, nevertheless made up the greater and more important part of the kingdom of Alba. Further, Kenneth seemed to claim that kingdom for himself by right, because Hungus, or Oengus, or Ungus, King of the Picts, who had given his sister in marriage to Achaius, King of the Scots, had so agreed that, if he himself left no heir, his sister's children should take the kingdom. She bore Alpin to Achaius, whose son was Kenneth, hence called Mac-Alpin. When, then, Hungus, and shortly afterwards his two sons, had died without offspring, the Scots claimed the kingdom for Alpin. The Picts, although no one of the royal stock survived, placed on the dead man's throne someone else of their own nation, named Feredeth; and after him some others, who held power for no long space of time. It was not fitting, then, for the Scots to pursue their right by arms. This succeeded with a less prosperous beginning, their King Alpin himself being slain when he was passing the third year of his reign. Kenneth his son at length in the fifth year, of Christ 840, routed the Picts, King Druskenus, or Druskon, having been killed, and joined that kingdom to his own: not, however, he subjugated it by arms, (although the Scottish writers affirm it) with the whole Pictish progeny cut off, except for slender remnants, of which part fled to the English and was also utterly destroyed by them not long afterwards, part to the Danes. Perhaps he destroyed with the sword the nobility that rebelled rather often, and emptied, by slaughtering the inhabitants, such towns as had resisted more stubbornly, without also running riot in the slaughter of the surrendered and unwarlike common people, and that a Christian one, being himself a Christian and pious, as the Scots proclaim. yet the whole nation was not destroyed: Gradually, however, from that time the Pictish name died out, and both nations were thereafter called Scots. Kenneth reigned from about the year 834 to 855. That there was present with him

[6] In the handwritten Irish Martyrologies, which John Colgan once communicated to us on February 23 (as we noted on that day), the memory of Saints Mandanus, or Montanus, and Tianus or Tiamanus is said to be celebrated: he is not the same as St. Mannanus known to the Irish on February 23, whom Colgan himself in volume 1 of the Acts of the Saints of Ireland calls Mannanus, or Monnanus, and Tiaanus or Tianus: and he expresses some doubt whether the former might not be St. Monan, whom we treat of here, and the latter St. Adrian, Bishop and Martyr, who is venerated on March 4. But he posits as the sole support of his conjecture a certain similarity of names (which indeed is of slight importance) and that St. Monnanus is called a vigorous champion in some Martyrology or Heortologion that he cites, by which he thinks is signified that he was a Martyr, and therefore appears to be St. Monan, who was also a Martyr. But neither did St. Monan undergo martyrdom, as we said before, and even one who was not a Martyr can sometimes be called a vigorous champion. What then is the reason why one who among the Scots, where he lived, is venerated on March 1, should among the Irish in Aradh-huird, or Aredh-Suird (for he writes it both ways), be venerated on February 23? Rightly therefore we relegated that Mandanus, or Mannanus, and Tianus on that day to the list of those Saints whose veneration, decreed to them by the Church or bestowed by the most ancient piety of the peoples, was not sufficiently proved to us: since Colgan himself confesses that nothing at all is established about them — not their age, not their deeds, not their rank — but only some ignoble place, whose age and deeds are unknown, where their memory is gathered to have once flourished, from notes written some centuries before. But it is surprising that Colgan, who there timidly put forth his conjecture, when he knew that Saints Monan and Adrian and their companions are said by Hector Boece to have been gathered together as a band from the Scots or the English, did not himself also refer them to the first and fourth days of March as originating from Ireland: surprising too why he did not divine that his Mannan was St. Marnan, of whom we have treated on this very day; since that name seems to come closer to this one, and the acts of St. Marnan have not been clearly explored by the Scots. But this too must be corrected in Colgan's narrative, that he writes that the Isle of May lies between Ireland and Britain, namely on the western side of the latter, whereas it is on the opposite side of Britain, in the estuary of the Forth, which, called Boderia by Ptolemy in book 2, chapter 3, table 1 of Europe, and Bodotria by Tacitus in the Life of Agricola, chapter 25, mingles with the German Ocean on the eastern coast of Scotland.

LIFE OF ST. MONAN

From the old Aberdeen Breviary.

Monan, Archdeacon of St. Andrews in Scotland (Saint)

BHL Number: 5993

[1] The glorious Confessor of Christ Monan, a born in the province of Pannonia of the region of Hungary, was of that company which, with Blessed Adrian, Prelate and most holy man, were slain by the b Noricans or Dacians, then pagans, St. Monan, companion of St. Adrian, Bishop and Martyr. on the Isle of May, which stands surrounded by the waves of the sea, and were crowned with Martyrdom. But before the aforesaid company of Martyrs had been consumed by martyrdom on the aforesaid island, Blessed Monan, upheld by a burning love of the Christian religion, went from the same island to the nearest shore to preach the word of salvation to the people of the land, he preaches in Scotland, and in the place which is called Inverny in Fife, where his holy relics now rest, he chose by divine guidance a dwelling: in which, devoted above all to divine services, he happily ended his days. and dies piously.

[2] For at his tomb the power which shone in him while living does not cease openly to show, around the body of him now dead, that he is honored in heaven; since you may see sight given to the blind, hearing to the deaf, the lame walking everywhere, bodies with contracted limbs made stretched out and straight, His tomb famous for miracles, demoniacs and the mentally deranged made whole, and all restored to health from every kind of disease by the patronage and merits of Blessed Monan, and every just desire obtained and helped. Each of which things, lest they should weary the readers, is confined in a few words. But of how great merit Blessed Monan was with God the abundant concourse of pilgrims to his tomb testifies to this day. and therefore also for the concourse of pilgrims:

[3] For although, after the ascent of this blessed man to heaven, a humble chapel contained his precious relics in this world, until the time of the most glorious Prince David, c King of the Scots, the second of the same name, most warlike and strenuous, who, on account of the recovery from various diseases of the same King churches and monasteries built at it by King David II and of others of his kingdom through the merits of Blessed Monan, built a quite sumptuous church in reverence of the said Confessor and to the honor of God: and he endowed it with very many and quite notable possessions for the support of religious men there.

[4] It happened meanwhile, in a d battle joined against the English by the aforesaid King, that he was mortally wounded by an iron and barbed arrow, which is commonly called a catapult: which could not be healed by the art of physicians or the remedy of surgeons, who, mortally wounded, so that all feared the death rather than the life of the King. At length, abandoning all the arts of medicines, e he hastened to St. Monan, solemnly making a vow: which done, that iron arrow of its own accord sprang out of the said King's wound, a vow having been made to him, he is wonderfully healed: and he was made sound and unharmed without a scar.

[5] A mother of a family, honorable indeed and adorned with distinguished parents, was made raving by a pitiable chance, so much so that, led by fury and the madness of anger, instigated by the malignant spirit, she tried to tear to pieces her parents who had begotten her and the children she herself had brought forth, and, like a biting dog, against nature, to rend them. A raving energumen healed at the tomb of St. Monan. Bound at length and placed in the strongest chains, she is brought by her parents to St. Monan: for whose deliverance her parents poured out most devout prayers to God and to Blessed Monan: and when the poor woman had rested a little and been awakened again, by the merits of Blessed Monan the demons who occupied the body of the same woman went out with very great howlings, leaving her half dead. On their departure she was at once restored to her former health, blessing the Lord everywhere in his deeds.

Annotations Page

Notes

a. Of what nation St. Monan seems to have been born we have said in the preliminary commentary, and shall say again on the 4th of March at the Life of St. Adrian, Bishop and Martyr.
b. [Dacians put for Danes,] The Danes are found to be called by the name of Dacians by many writers of the middle age, although these were different nations and very far removed from each other. The Noricans too are taken for the Norwegians or Northmen, especially among certain authors of English history: whereas of old the Noricans were neighbors to the Raetians, the Vindelicians, the Boii, and on the east the Pannonians, bounded on the north by the river Danube. Yet if anyone should derive the name from the word Nort, which in Teutonic signifies the North, [Noricans for Norwegians.] so that Noricum should be Nort-rijck, that is, the Northern kingdom, I should assent to him more easily indeed than to the fable which is related by Lazius from I know not what annals about Noricus the son of Hercules, who conquered the Boii, the inhabitants of that region, newcomers from Armenia: whereas the Boii themselves, originating from Gaul, took their abodes in Noricum.
c. [David II, King of Scotland.] David II succeeded his father Robert Bruce in the kingdom of Scotland about the year 1329, almost a boy: he died in 1370, having been harassed through the whole time of his reign by many tribulations, which the writers of Scottish history narrate at length: of whom one, a man otherwise by no means good, yet notes this well, that fortune always seemed to have failed him more than industry.
d. Boece will have it that this happened when David was captured by the English: "when, surrounded," he says, "by so great a number, having already received two wounds, with the darts still sticking in his body, he could not break through." And certainly others too admit that the King was then wounded. Henry Knighton, a writer of that time, book 4 *On the Events of England*, at the year 1346 (not, as others, 1348), has this: "The King of Scotland fled from the battle, [captured by the English.] and was wounded by an arrow in the head, and captured at Meryngton by a valet of John Coupelande." But Buchanan, book 9: "The King himself," he says, "was captured by John Copland, two of whose teeth he had knocked out with his fist after his weapons had been snatched from him, but already gravely wounded by two arrows." How then could he set out to the Saint's church, as the same Boece indicates, when he was held captive among the English?
e. Boece: "But one dart fixed in the King's shin could not be extracted at once, nor before he visited St. Ninian. For then the shin was seen manifestly to open, and the dart to leap out." But St. Ninian, Bishop of Candida Casa and Apostle of the Southern Picts, [St. Ninian the Bishop.] is different from St. Mynnan, or Monan, four hundred years older than Mynnan. We shall give his Life on the 16th of September. David Camerarius reports that the King was cured by the kindness of St. Monan, not of St. Ninian, writing expressly thus: "King David, placing all his hope in God, and recalling to memory the miracles which He was working through his servant Monan, is conducted to Inverny, where his tomb was, accompanied by the Nobles of the kingdom," etc. And having narrated the miracle he appends this: [The church and tomb of St. Monan at Inverny.] "In perpetual memory of this benefit King David caused a most sumptuous church to be built there in honor of Blessed Monan, and was the first to place Priests in that collegiate Church to celebrate the divine mysteries, revenues having been assigned."

Feedback

Noticed an error, have a suggestion, or want to share a thought? Let me know.